Electric vs Acoustic Guitar for Beginners: Which to Buy

For most beginners, the question of electric guitar vs acoustic for beginners comes down to one thing: what music do you want to play? Acoustic guitar requires no extra gear and is cheaper to get started with — a decent beginner acoustic runs $150–$300 all-in. Electric guitar has a lower action (string height), making it physically easier to press down chords, but you'll need an amp, cable, and potentially pedals, bringing the startup cost to $300–$500+. Neither is inherently "harder" — the best guitar is the one that plays the music you love.

Cost Comparison: What You Actually Need to Buy

• Beginner acoustic guitar: $150–$300 (e.g., Yamaha FG800, Fender CD-60S)
• Picks, capo, strap: $20–$30
• Clip-on tuner: $10–$20
• Total: $180–$350

• Beginner electric guitar: $200–$350 (e.g., Squier Stratocaster, Epiphone Les Paul)
• Practice amp (15–20W): $80–$150 (e.g., Fender Frontman 15G, Boss Katana Mini)
• Cable: $15–$25
• Picks, strap, tuner: $25–$40
• Total: $320–$565

Acoustic wins on entry cost by $100–$200. However, if you already have a phone, a free amp-sim app (like GarageBand or Positive Grid Spark) can reduce the electric startup cost significantly — some players run directly into an interface for $50 and skip the amp entirely.

Playability: Which Is Actually Easier to Learn?

This is where the conventional wisdom often misleads beginners.

• Higher string action (distance from strings to fretboard)
• Heavier gauge strings (usually .012–.053) requiring more finger pressure
• Wider necks on many models
• No tone-shaping electronics — what you play is what you hear

• Lower action (easier to press down)
• Lighter strings (usually .009–.046)
• Narrower necks (easier chord shapes for smaller hands)
• Onboard controls for volume and tone

In purely physical terms, electric guitar is easier on your fretting hand. Barre chords — the biggest hurdle for most beginners — require significantly less force on a properly set-up electric. Many adult beginners with hand strength concerns or joint issues find electric much more comfortable.

That said, acoustic guitar builds finger strength faster. Many guitar teachers argue that starting acoustic makes you a stronger player, and that switching to electric later feels like a bonus. It's a valid perspective — just don't let it override what actually motivates you to practice.

Tone and Genre: Which Matches Your Goals?

This is the single most important factor for long-term success. Beginners who practice the music they love quit less.

• Folk, country, bluegrass
• Singer-songwriter material
• Campfire playing and travel
• Classical or fingerstyle
• Budget-conscious players

• Rock, metal, punk
• Blues
• Jazz
• Funk and R&B
• Players who want to use effects pedals

• Pop
• Indie
• Worship/church music
• Basic chord-based playing

One important point: acoustic isn't "acoustic only." An electro-acoustic with a built-in pickup can be plugged into a PA for live performance. And an unplugged electric can be practiced quietly at home (though it sounds thin without amplification).

Noise and Practice Environment Considerations

If you live in an apartment or share a space with others, amplifier volume matters.

• Acoustic guitar is inherently louder acoustically — you can't turn it down. A full-size dreadnought at full strumming volume is around 65–75 dB, comparable to a conversation.
• Electric guitar unplugged is very quiet. Plugged into a headphone amp (~$30–$80) or using headphone output on modern practice amps (like the Fender Mustang LT25), you can practice at midnight without waking anyone.

For apartment dwellers, electric guitar often wins on practicality despite the higher entry cost.

Which Should You Buy? A Decision Framework

Ask yourself these questions:

1. What artists do I want to sound like? If the answer is Ed Sheeran, Taylor Swift, or John Denver — acoustic. If the answer is Jimi Hendrix, John Mayer, or Tom Morello — electric.
2. What's my budget? Under $250 all-in? Acoustic is the realistic choice.
3. Do I live somewhere where volume is an issue? Electric with headphone practice wins.
4. Do I have hand or joint issues? Electric's lower action may be more comfortable.
5. Do I want to gig eventually? Either works, but electric gives you more tonal options for band settings.

If you genuinely can't decide, many teachers recommend starting acoustic and switching to electric after 3–6 months. You'll have built foundational technique and will immediately appreciate how much easier the electric feels.

FAQ

Is acoustic or electric guitar easier for beginners? Electric guitar is physically easier because of lower action and lighter strings. Acoustic guitar builds finger strength faster and requires no extra equipment. Beginners who prioritize physical ease tend to prefer electric; those who prioritize simplicity and lower cost tend to prefer acoustic. Both are valid starting points.

Can I teach myself guitar on either type? Yes. Thousands of self-taught guitarists have started on both acoustic and electric using YouTube tutorials, apps like Yousician, and online courses. A teacher accelerates progress on either instrument, but self-teaching is absolutely viable on both.

Should I start on acoustic before moving to electric? This is a common recommendation, but it's not a rule. If your musical goals are primarily electric — rock, blues, metal — starting on electric is perfectly fine. There's no harm in starting where your motivation is highest.

Find the Right Guitar at PGL

Whether you go acoustic or electric, the right instrument at the right setup makes a measurable difference in how fast you progress. Browse our full beginner guitar reviews, gear comparisons, and buying guides at [professionalgl.com/knowledge-hub](https://professionalgl.com/knowledge-hub) — or use our Pro Concierge to get a personalized recommendation based on your budget and music goals.

Related Reading

• Learn more: [Beginner Guitarist Complete Setup Guide](/knowledge-hub/beginner-guitarist-complete-setup-guide)
• Learn more: [Best Guitar Strings for Beginners](/knowledge-hub/best-guitar-strings-for-beginners)

For more on this topic, see our <a href="/knowledge-hub/2026-05-29-best-electric-guitar-for-beginners-under-300">best electric guitars for beginners under $300</a> guide.

For more on this topic, see our <a href="/knowledge-hub/2026-05-30-best-acoustic-guitar-under-500">best acoustic guitars under $500</a> guide.

---

Ready to upgrade your guitar gear? Browse our full selection of beginner guitars — both electric and acoustic — at [PGL Music Store](/shop) and use our [Gear Finder Quiz](/gear-finder) to find the perfect first guitar for your style and budget. Free shipping available on qualifying orders.